Background 2022 AACC Poster #132 of the same title described how the Westgard sigma metric equation of [A] SM = (TEa - Bias)/SD proposed by James O. Westgard is NOT wrong when compared to the industrial practice of calculating sigma as [B] the difference between the mean and nearest upper or lower tolerance limit divided by the SD. Formulae [A] and [B] produce the same results. The often-recommended practice of calculating sigma as [C] Sigma = (%TE -|%Bias|)/CV%, however, produces results that differ from either formulae described above whenever bias is not zero. This formula [C] using percentages is therefore wrong. Methods Sigma values were calculated as [A] (TEa - |Bias)|/SD and as [C] (%TE - |%Bias|)/CV% on fourteen routine chemistry analytes and four cardiac markers tested on two Ortho Vitros 5600 analysers from September to December 2022. CLIA TEa limits were selected as TEa limits for each analyte; bias was calculated as Current Mean - Peer Mean. Sigma tables were used to convert sigma to defects per million results. Eight-six of 320 data sets with sigma metrics from 2.25 to 5.25 were graphed to compare calculated sigma values and #failures/year. Results Comparison of sigma metrics calculated from formula [A] and [C] revealed

  1. An R² = 1.00 if all 320 values with sigma metrics from 0.71 to 30.8;
  2. An R² = 0.92 when the range was truncated to the 86 samples with sigma from 2.25 to 5.25; and
  3. An R² value of only 0.75 when the same sigma values are converted to the number of results failing TEa limits per one million patent samples. Sigma Metric Equation Proposed by James O. Westgard is Wrong Zoe. C. BROOKS. AWEsome Numbers Inc, Worthington, ON, Canada, B-155 Conclusion: Calculations of sigma metrics based on %Bias and %CV are incorrect. This is exacerbated when sigma is converted to the number of patient failures per million results Sigma from Units of Measure = 3.00 Sigma from Percent = 2.82 What decisions do you make based on sigma metrics?? Sigma from Percent = Sigma from Units of Measure ONLY if bias = zero . y = 1.04x – 0.14 R² = 0.92 2.25 2.75 3.25 3.75 4.25 4.75 5.25 2.25 2.75 3.25 3.75 4.25 4.75 5.25 [C] Sigma =(TEa%-|bias%|)/CV% [A] Sigma = (TEa-|bias|)/SD Sigma Value from % vs. Sigma Value from Units y = 0.7447x + 126.49 R² = 0.7526 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 [C] Sigma = (TEa%-|bias%|)/CV% [A] Sigma = (TEa-|bias|)/SD Failures /million Patient Samples ÷ 6 2 = ?? Compare calculations of Sigma and Total Error from units of measure and percent Formulae Units/Result Calculations Units/Result Calculations Units/Result Calculations Measured Mean FACT: Measured from individual QC results 100.00 106.00 94.00 True Value Opinion: Selected from Peer, Package insert or history 100.00 100.00 100.00 Bias from Units (Mean - True) 0.00 100 - 100 6.00 106 - 100 -6.00 94 - 100 Bias as Percent of True Bias/True 0.0% 0 / 100 6.0% 6 / 100 -6.0% -6 / 100 Medical Goal (TEa) Opinion: Selected from Medical Goal or Proficiency 12.00 12.00 12.00 Medical Goal (TEa) TEa/True 12.0% 12 / 100 12.0% 12 / 100 12.0% 12 / 100 Measured SD FACT: Measured from individual QC results 2.00 2.00 2.00 CV% CV% = SD/Mean 2.00% 2 / 100 1.89% 2 / 106 2.13% 2 / 94 Sigma (z-value to TEa) (TEa-|Bias|)/SD 6.00 = (12 - |0|)/2 3.00 = (12 - |6|)/2 3.00 = (12 - |-6|)/2 Sigma metric from % (TEa% - |Bias%|/CV% 6.00 =(12% - |0%|)/2% 3.17 =(12% - |6%|)/1.89% 2.82 =(12% - |6%|)/2.13% Sigma from Units of Measure = 3.00 Sigma from Percent = 3.17